“Women [are] the builders of a Muslim society… [We are] committed to all rights of women that have been given to them by the sacred religion of Islam,” Taliban spokesperson Zabihullah Mujahid said in a statement delivered shortly after their rapid takeover of Afghanistan.
But despite the Taliban’s promises, Afghan women’s hopes for education and freedoms may have died the day the United States decided to withdraw from Afghanistan.
Background of U.S. involvement in Afghanistan and Taliban rule
In 11 seconds, the twin towers crumbled. Almost three thousand people died, and the World Trade Center, a structure that took 14 years to build, collapsed in less than a day. The devastating 9/11 terrorist attack, spearheaded by al-Qaida, was a pivotal moment in U.S. history, setting the tone for Afghanistan and U.S. relations for the next 20 years.
Shortly after the attack, President George W. Bush announced that American military forces would instigate attacks against the terrorist group and Taliban targets in Afghanistan, marking the start of Operation Enduring Freedom.
At the time, the Taliban controlled most of Afghanistan. Their rule was characterized by harsh punishments and severe restrictions on the freedoms of women.
From the time girls in Afghanistan turned eight years old, their lives were subject to the whims of men. They could not appear outside without a blood relative, be in contact with a male unless a close relative, and mandated to wear burqas in public. They could not wear heeled shoes, as no man should hear a woman’s footsteps, and had to speak quietly in public, as no male stranger should hear a woman’s voice. They were forbidden to be photographed, be seen on balconies, or attend public gatherings.
Yet despite the oppressive conditions of women, what truly angered the United States was the Taliban sympathy towards extremist groups like al-Qaida. After 9/11, Bush demanded the leaders and those involved in the attack be handed to the United States. When the Taliban rejected Bush’s demand to turn over the al-Qaida leaders in charge of 9/11, the president launched his war on terrorism, stating, “Now the Taliban will pay a price.”
Soon after, Taliban leaders fled Afghanistan and found refuge in Pakistan. The American military did not follow; instead, they stayed in Afghanistan and overturned the Taliban government.
By December, the Taliban offered an unconditional surrender, which Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld promptly rejected. He refused to grant amnesty to Taliban leader Mohammad Omar, and they could not reach a compromise.
The United States remained in Afghanistan, and with the assistance of NATO, spent billions of dollars in an effort to Westernize the nation.
Initially, it seemed like there was hope for improvement; new buildings and facilities were built, and a pro-Western government was installed.
The most drastic change that came out of these reparations was their impact on women’s rights. Prior to U.S. intervention, the Taliban prohibited Afghan girls from attending school, confining them to their homes. But now, thousands of girls were allowed to pursue a college-level education, find a job, be heard in their communities, and even serve in the newly democratic government.
But despite the positive changes, corruption was everywhere. According to a 2020 report by Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR), “a total of approximately $19 billion, or 30% of the [$63 billion] amount reviewed, was lost to waste, fraud, and abuse.”
In addition to rampant corruption, the government was still unable to meet the needs of Afghan citizens, despite the progress in infrastructure and women’s rights.
These underlying issues, coupled with Afghanistan’s anti-colonialism cry fueled by the presence of U.S. troops, enabled the Taliban to begin rebuilding. They continued to grow stronger, and by 2010, President Obama had deployed nearly 100,000 troops in an attempt to cripple the Taliban.
It was ineffective. The Taliban only continued to grow, prompting Obama to retract US troops.
“President Obama has asked the Pentagon to ensure that it has adequate plans in place to accomplish an orderly withdrawal by the end of the year should the United States not keep any troops in Afghanistan after 2014,” the White House said in a statement published that year.
Two years later, Obama’s second term as president ended, passing the burden of Afghan-U.S. relations to the conservative Trump administration.
In Febuary of 2020, President Trump signed a peace deal with the Taliban. The deal was an agreement between the U.S. and the Taliban, negotiating an accord to bring peace to Afghanistan. However, representatives of the Afghan government were absent during the making of this deal.
“We think we’ll be successful in the end,” Trump said.
The Secretary of State, Mike Pompeo, followed up Trump’s statement proclaiming that the administration was taking the right steps for future coexistence between the nations.
“We are seizing the best opportunity for peace in a generation,” Pompeo said.
In 2021, the Trump administration passed the situation over to the new Biden administration, who chose to uphold the peace agreement.
U.S. withdrawal
Twenty years later, after a lengthy, turbulent struggle, the U.S. made an unforeseen decision to withdraw all troops from the territory. Biden withdrew all U.S. troops from Afghanistan, claiming he was “boxed in” by Trump’s deal with the Taliban.
However, contrary to his statement, Biden was not bound to the agreement. The accord had an escape clause: If the Afghan peace talks failed, the U.S. could withdraw from the deal.
The peace talks did fail, providing Biden with the opportunity to remain in the nation. However, he chose not to, instead opting to uphold the deal but prolong the removal of troops from May to September.
“The United States did what we went to do in Afghanistan: to get the terrorists who attacked us on 9/11 and to deliver justice to Osama Bin Laden, and to degrade the terrorist threat to keep Afghanistan from becoming a base from which attacks could be continued against the United States. We achieved those objectives,” said President Joe Biden in his July 8 speech on the withdrawal of troops. “We did not go to Afghanistan to nation-build. And it’s the right and the responsibility of the Afghan people alone to decide their future and how they want to run their country.”
But though the United States did not come to Afghanistan with the intention to nation-build, they did just that. The United States spent decades at war in the nation, drastically changing the way of life for its citizens. Women were starting to break away from the history of oppression that characterized their lives in Afghanistan. But with the Taliban now in power, all of that may slip away.
Implications for women
As the United States rapidly withdrew from Afghanistan, the Taliban quickly followed their retreat. They soon overtook and established control over the entirety of the nation, shocking the world.
“The Taliban takeover is definitely something that is very disconcerting and also very disappointing,” said John Black,* a Carlmont senior who wishes to remain anonymous. Black’s close friends served in Afghanistan, and he wants to ensure the safety of their interpreters and aides, who are still stuck in Afghanistan. “Overall, the Taliban takeover is bad news for a majority of the Afghan people.”
Though Black’s friends have returned to the U.S., their thoughts are of the country they left behind. They remain fearful and disappointed with the outcome and fear for their comrades who cannot leave.
“They feel like it was poorly handled and is also devastating for the locals and the interpreters they worked with,” Black said. “They were afraid of what may happen to them since the Taliban is extremely anti-American and hostile to Western sympathizers.”
To ease the world’s worries of the implications of their takeover, the Taliban delivered a lengthy statement. They made a promise to respect the rights of women granted from the religion of Islam.
“We want to build the future and forget what happened in the past,” Mujahid, said in an interview with The New York Times.
The Taliban have promised their rule this time will be different. Women will be allowed to work and attend school, they say. They will have respect. They will have all the rights granted to them by Islam.
But the past does not disappear so easily. Despite their assurances of progress and freedom for women, many doubt their intentions. Thousands of Afghan men, women, and children fled the country or went into hiding, fearful for their lives.
“[The Taliban’s] statements regarding women’s rights are not going to be honored at all. Their promises for women will not be honored,” Black said. “We’ve seen what these people have done in the past, and it honestly doesn’t really look like anything is going to change.”
Black’s predictions look as if they are coming to pass. Already, the Taliban — amidst its promises to be more moderate — has imposed new restrictions on women. Some female sports, such as cricket, have been banned. Schools will be segregated by gender, leading to fears of a more restricted education. Islamic dress codes will be enforced. And women are afraid.
"Afghanistan is hell for women to live," said Dr. Massouda Jalal, the only woman to run for president in Afghanistan, in an interview for People Magazine. "Women of Afghanistan are already in the worst status in the world, but if such ideologies are coming into power like [the ones that are] now in power, women will go the worst — the worst, the worst.”
*This source wishes to remain anonymous to protect his friends’ identities and ensure the safety of their interpreters and aides still in Afghanistan. His name was changed is in accordance with Carlmont Media’s Anonymous Sourcing Policy.
Taliban control of Afghanistan provinces as of August 2021
Overview of the four parts of Trump's peace treaty with the Taliban
Part 1:
Guarantees and enforcement mechanisms that will prevent the use of the soil of Afghanistan by any group or individual against the security of the United States and its allies.
Part 2:
Guarantees, enforcement mechanisms, and announcement of a timeline for the withdrawal of all foreign forces from Afghanistan.
Part 3:
After the announcement of guarantees for a complete withdrawal of foreign forces and associated timeline in the presence of international witnesses, and guarantees and the announcement in the presence of international witnesses that Afghan soil will not be used against the security of the United States and its allies, the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, which is not recognized by the United States as a state and is known as the Taliban, will start intra-Afghan negotiations with Afghan sides on March 10, 2020, which corresponds to Rajab 15, 1441 on the Hijri Lunar calendar and Hoot 20, 1398 on the Hijri Solar calendar.
Part 4:
A permanent and comprehensive ceasefire will be an item on the agenda of the intra-Afghan dialogue and negotiations. The participants of intra-Afghan negotiations will discuss the date and modalities of a permanent and comprehensive ceasefire, including joint implementation mechanisms, which will be announced along with the completion and agreement over the future political roadmap of Afghanistan.
Attribution for feature video:
Joe Biden / Gage Skidmore / CC BY 2.0
Women wears green headscarf / Pxfuel / Public Domain
US Military and Civilian personnel assigned to the Civil Military Operations / Marshall Emerson / U.S. Military / Public Domain
Royal Marines Storm a Taliban Compound in 2007 / Gaz Faulkner / CC BY-NC 2.0
9/11 WTC 32 / Michael Foran / (cc) 2001 Michael Foran
Office of the Administrator - President Obama / The U.S. National Archives / Public Domain
President George W. Bush and Secretary of State Colin Powell Remarks from Rose Garden on Executive Order / The U.S. National Archives / Public Domain
Trump accepts nomination / The Voice of America / Voanews.com / Public Domain
Afghan Girl / John Scott Rafoss / Afghanistan Matters / CC BY 2.0
Women's Self Help Group in Badakhshan / Canada in Afghanistan / Flickr / CC BY-NC-ND 2.0
A class of young Afghan Women Attending a class at Shahid Syed Padsha School, during a MEDCAP / Leslie Angulo / U.S. Army / Public Domain
Attribution for photo:
Afghan girl / Afghanistan matters / Wikimedia commons/ CC BY-SA 2.0